Demotion of 1qaz2wsx3edc4rfv | Fandom

Pscj·3/17/2015 in Site Administration

Demotion of 1qaz2wsx3edc4rfv

Hi, I'm Pscj, one the Bureaucrats and Administrators of the Shokugeki no Soma Wiki.

It has come to my attention that 1qaz2wsx3edc4rfv, a bureaucrat and our founder of our wiki is no longer active for about a year or so and his only contributions to the wiki as of today are creating the wiki itself. My assumptions are that he made the wiki on a whim and left it there for someone to pick it up afterwards.

Regardless, I would like to request his status of being a Bureaucrat removed, as he has never made any significant contribution to the site itself and has not met any of the requirements in being a bureaucrat.

After sending a request to Central Wikia requesting the user's demotion. They stated that they generally do not remove rights from Bureaucrats unless it is clear that there is a community consensus to do so.

So, without further ado, let us open a forum for the site to discuss on whether or not 1qaz2wsx3edc4rfv should be removed of his/her rights. The discussion system is simple:

Type {{Support}} for those in favor of having his rights removed, and provide a simple valid reason on why the user should be removed of his/her rights.

Or type {{Oppose}} for those in favor of having him retain his position as an Admin, Bureaucrat and the representative of this wiki.

Please also note that accounts created after this discussion was made is not allowed to make any form of reply as to users that have not contributed to the wiki at all.

Thank you for your attention.

(Edited by Pscj)

0

Jwjchsr·3/17/2015

Support - If the user is no longer active, why should he keep his right? On top of that, he hasn't made a contribution in a while. Sounds like enough of a justiable cause to demote him so others can try to obtain Bureaucrats status/right.

(Edited by Jwjchsr)

0

HellKaiserN·3/17/2015

Support - I can understand the founder in this situation. He probably liked the manga and started the wiki, as nobody had thought of it as of yet. However, he just didn't find the time to actively edit and probably didn't think of the responsibilities that come with a Bureaucrat-status. Anyone can start a wiki, but for the wiki to succeed, a Bureaucrat would have to do as much as he can. You have to earn it. In this case, the founder didn't find time to do so, and thus I so no reason why he should keep his Bureaucrats-status.

(Edited by HellKaiserN)

0

Nauibotics·3/17/2015

Support - - While I am grateful that he created this wiki, he has not done anything else except for its creation. Comparatively, although I did not create this wiki, I am one of the most prolific editors of the site and one of the reasons why we are currently on track to repairing some of the errors made on this site. Because of this I became a Bureaucrat to help take charge of the wiki. A Bureaucrat needs to be on frequently and contribute on a regular basis to make this wiki the best it can. For this reason, 1qaz2wsx3edc4rfv has not fulfilled this important aspect and thus should not keep his Bureaucrat status.

(Edited by Nauibotics)

0

Pscj·3/18/2015

Support - I too, have to express my dissatisfaction for a user which has little to no contribution on this site to hold such an important position in the wiki itself. And I believe to give other users an opportunity to obtain this position if they fulfilled the requirements on this wiki. This user, as we speak, has not achieved any of the following requirements of being one and therefore sets a bad example for all the users here that have fought for or will fight for claiming this position. So, as my statements above suggests, I would like to have his rights removed.

(Edited by Pscj)

0

Chingaruna517·3/22/2015

Support --I might as well support about it as well. As a admin in my personal wikia, I believed that it is essential for a wikia founder to be active in the wikia in all times (well if he can keep that up that is).

(Edited by Chingaruna517)

0

Pscj·3/23/2015

The staff in Central has now officially removed 1qaz2wsx3edc4rfv from his rights. As proven from his profile, which has now been removed of its rights, and its existence, he is no longer the Bureaucrat of our site any longer.

Thank you for those who have participated in this discussion.

(Edited by Pscj)

What do you think?